Robert Parker - 92 points
"The house’s NV Brut Rosé deCuvaison is another standout. Tar, smoke and game are some of the aromas and flavors that emerge from the glass, adding considerable complexity and nuance. A short maceration on the skinks gives this 100% Pinot Noir Champagne its volume and breadth. Richness and sophistication meld together beautifully here. This is a standout from Moutard. Disgorged July 2012. Anticipated maturity: 2012-2017."
Wine Spectator - 91 points
"Earth and mineral notes accent flavors of strawberry, black currant and ground spices in this firmly structured rosé Champagne, which is full-bodied, vibrant and juicy, with a lip-smacking finish. Drink now through 2016."
Stephen Tanzer - 91 points
"Dark pink. Powerful, heady aromas of ripe red berries, potpourri and buttered toast. Smoky and broad, offering intense raspberry and cherry flavors and a bracing mineral quality. Shows impressive density and focus, finishing at length on a spicy note. A substantial pink Champagne that also has very good balance and energy."